Almost 20 years after deregulation of the Australian dairy industry, Labor has flagged a potential return to government intervention in the market. If elected in May, a Labor Government will task the ACCC to assess and test the efficacy of a Minimum Farm Gate Milk Price1 and to make recommendations on the best design options.
The AFI research team has produced this briefing to discuss how might this impact the industry and what we already know about floor prices in Australian agriculture.
Milk is a global commodity and dairy farmers are price takers. Unlike many countries around the world, there is no legislative control in Australia over the price processing companies pay farmers for their milk. Australian dairy farmers have operated in a completely deregulated industry environment since 1 July 2000, when all states repealed legislation governing sourcing and pricing of drinking milk, and the state milk authorities, which administered these controls, were wound up2. Prior to 2000, the dairy industry was long one of the most highly assisted and regulated industries in Australia3. Immediately after deregulation, Woolworths announced standard national prices for its generic-labelled milk4 that effectively created a new floor price, as other major retailers (Coles, IGA and Franklins) soon followed suit.
At an average of around US42c per litre, Australian dairy farmers receive a low price by world standards. ABARES expects Australian farmgate milk prices to remain relatively unchanged in 2018–195, due to export price premiums for some commodities, competition among major processors for suppliers and an assumed fall in the Australian dollar.
AFI commentary on dairy issues
In 2013, then-AFI Executive Director Mick Keogh wrote about the drought conditions in NZ affecting the global milk price, noting that if the Australian industry was functioning correctly it should follow the global market with increased farmgate prices flowing on to the consumer6. From 2013 to 2014 there was a rise in farmgate milk prices7, however the retail price of supermarket-branded milk remained unchanged over this period at $1/L.
In the Autumn 2013 Farm Policy Journal Freshagenda Director Steve Spencer discussed the Horizon 2020 project investigation8 into the complex issues surrounding dairy market influences9 – including a decline in NSW/Qld milk production following deregulation, significant consolidation in processing ownership and capacity and changes in supply contracts – concluding that in effect the “actual impact of the lower retail pricing has not been as great as the industry feared”.
A 2016 blog post by the AFI10 discussed the sharing of risk along the supply chain which indicated the disproportionate level of jeopardy on farmers rather than processors and noted the need to modernise “outdated” marketing arrangements in sectors such as dairy.
Fundamental issues for Australia’s dairy industry were discussed by Dr Peter Stahle, Australian Dairy Products Federation Executive Director, and David Basham, Australian Dairy Farmers Acting President, in the November 2016 Farm Institute Insights Newsletter’s ‘In My View’ feature11. Both contributors noted the strong influence of the global market on domestic dairy prices and the need for improvement in contractual supply agreements.
ACCC inquiry findings
Due to the level of adversity the Australian dairy sector has faced over the past decade, the ACCC was commissioned to conduct an inquiry into the industry’s performance. The report12 (published in April 2018) covered supply chains, bargaining power and risk allocation, concluding that establishing a mandatory code of conduct is the best option to improve the position of farmers in the dairy supply chain.
The report also included recommendations on simplifying contracts, ensuring that contracts will not unreasonably restrict farmers from switching between processors, utilising mediation between farmers and processors. It did not recommend reconsidering regulation.
Of the 112 submissions received by the ACCC, only one representative group submitted that new legislation or reregulation should be considered to set prices and deal with alleged anti-competitive behaviour. The report noted that the industry has consolidated since deregulation, and that national milk production has decreased by 15% but has become increasingly stable over the past decade. Evidence obtained by the ACCC found no direct relationship between retail private label milk prices and farmgate prices, and that:
- production volumes trended down in higher cost regions (Qld, WA) since price support was removed; the price of private label milk does not appear to have altered this trend
- farm exit trends in the higher cost regions have not changed in response to the introduction of $1/L milk
- total farm numbers, output and profitability trends have not changed since the introduction of $1/L milk
Effects of price floor on markets
Although now out of fashion with economists, the idea of a commodity price floor remains attractive to policy-makers. Price floors for agricultural commodities have been intensively used in global markets, such as the US and EU. However, this can have a negative impact on sustainable production and distort the correct functioning of markets by sending price signals that cause an unwanted accumulation of surplus product.
According to the ACCC report local milk demand is stagnant, meaning increases in prices would not incentivise processors to buy more milk and influence farmgate prices. In regions where milk is mainly produced for export, farmgate prices and profit reflect the global dairy commodity price changes.
Questions to consider
- What impact would a regulated price have on the dairy export market?
- Would a floor price lead to a supply management system such as that employed in Canada?15
- Has the attention on the $1/L price war distracted from the fundamental problems within the industry (e.g. disproportionate risk allocation between farmers and processors)?
- With Australian dairy producers being amongst the world’s most efficient, what impact might a floor price have on production efficiency?
- Press release: Labor will investigate a floor price for dairy farmers
- Dairy Australia: deregulation
- Edwards, 2003
- Australian Competition & Consumer Commission, 2001
- ABARES agricultural commodities: Sept 2018
- An interesting test ahead for the Australian milk market, (Keogh, March 2013)
- Freshagenda: Horizon 2020
- Spencer (2013), Dairy’s challenging horizon, Farm Policy Journal, Vol. 10, No. 1, pp. 13-29
- Is it time agricultural risk was shared along the supply chain? (Keogh, July 2016)
- November 2016: In My View – Fundamental issues for Australia’s dairy industry
- ACCC Dairy inquiry report (April 2018)
- A price floor is the minimum legal price set by the government, often used in agriculture to protect farmers’ incomes or to guarantee food supply.
- Bardsley, P. (1994). The Collapse of the Australian Wool Reserve Price Scheme, The Economic Journal, 104(426), 1087
- Time to get regulation back into Australian dairy? (Muirhead, 2016)